Weathered asphalt shingles on an older Boston house roof

· By

Will an Old Roof Stop Your Boston Home Sale?

An old roof can stop a Boston home sale if it keeps your buyer from getting homeowners insurance, which the lender requires before the loan closes. Many insurers look harder at asphalt shingle roofs somewhere around 15 to 20 years old, so check your roof's age and condition before you list.

Can an old roof stop your home sale in Boston?

It can. A buyer's lender requires homeowners insurance before the loan closes, and an older or worn roof can lead an insurer to decline a policy, offer more limited roof coverage, or charge more. Insurers set their own roof-age rules, and many start looking harder at asphalt shingle roofs somewhere around 15 to 20 years old. If you're selling a home in Jamaica Plain, Roslindale, Hyde Park, Dorchester, or Roxbury with an original or aging roof, it's worth understanding before you list, not after an offer runs into trouble.

Your situation depends on the roof's material, age, and condition, and the way to find out is to check before a buyer's lender or insurer does.

Key Takeaways

  • A buyer's lender requires homeowners insurance before the loan closes, and an older or worn roof can lead an insurer to decline a policy, limit roof coverage, or charge more.
  • Many insurers look harder at asphalt shingle roofs around 15 to 20 years old, and older roofs are often covered only at actual cash value.
  • Under Division of Insurance Bulletin 2025-02, cosmetic damage in aerial images shouldn't be the sole basis for a nonrenewal, cancellation, or declination.
  • A real nonrenewal comes from your insurer, with written notice at least 45 days before the policy expires and the specific reasons.
  • A documented professional roof inspection can sometimes satisfy a buyer's insurer without a full replacement.

How do insurers decide whether a roof is too old?

Each insurer sets its own rules. There's no single industry cutoff. Policygenius, a consumer insurance site, says insurers generally treat a roof older than about 15 years as old, that some won't cover a 20-year-old roof, and that older roofs are often covered only at actual cash value. Actual cash value subtracts depreciation, so a claim on an older roof pays less than the cost of a new one. What makes a roof uninsurable varies by insurance company, and a roof one insurer declines may be acceptable to another.

Insurers may also review roofs using aerial imagery. In Bulletin 2025-02 (April 30, 2025), the Massachusetts Division of Insurance set out its expectations for that practice: insurers may use aerial images but should make sure they are clear and accurate, cosmetic damage that doesn't reflect the property's structural condition shouldn't be the sole basis for a nonrenewal, cancellation, or declination, and when images don't show clear damage, insurers are expected to do more review, possibly including a physical inspection.

Massachusetts also has a market of last resort. The Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association, known as the FAIR Plan, offers Division of Insurance-approved homeowners and dwelling fire policies for eligible properties whose owners can't get insurance in the regular market. Ask an insurance agent how its coverage and cost compare with a private policy for a specific home.

Much of Boston's housing is decades old, with both pitched and flat roofs, so roof age is worth checking before any Boston sale.

How does an old roof affect selling your home?

It can delay or derail your buyer's financing. Your buyer needs proof of homeowners insurance before the lender funds the mortgage. If the roof's age or condition means the buyer's insurer won't bind a policy, or the premium changes the buyer's numbers, the deal can run into trouble late, sometimes after the inspection and sometimes during underwriting.

This is a different issue from wiring. Old knob-and-tube wiring raises fire-risk questions for underwriters. A roof question is about age and condition, and nearly every home eventually needs a new roof.

Replacing the roof before listing isn't automatically the right call. Sometimes a documented professional roof inspection showing the roof's condition is enough for a buyer's insurer, without a full replacement. Get contractor quotes for your specific roof before deciding, and see what to fix before you sell your Boston home and what to skip for the broader decision.

Are roof "flagged" mailers real insurance notices?

Not always: some come from marketers, not insurance companies. On November 5, 2025, the Massachusetts Division of Insurance issued a consumer advisory about mailers sent to Rhode Island residents by an entity called Home Coverage Risk Alert. The mailers said a home had been "flagged" for roof age or condition and suggested a premium increase or nonrenewal, but they did not come from an insurance company. The Division warned that Massachusetts residents might see similar notices, including offers of paid roof inspection reports or contractor referrals, and advised homeowners to check with their insurer or agent and not to authorize costly work based only on unsolicited marketing.

A real nonrenewal comes from your insurer. Massachusetts law requires an insurer to give written notice at least 45 days before a policy covering a home against fire expires if it won't renew, with the specific reasons (M.G.L. c.175 §193P). If a letter seems off, call your agent or insurer before you do anything else.

For sellers, a scary-looking mailer can push someone toward an expensive roof replacement right before listing, when a phone call would have shown the notice wasn't from their insurer.

What should you do about an older roof before you list?

Find out the roof's age and condition, and what documentation insurers will accept.

None of this means every seller with an older roof needs to replace it. Many sales close with a documented inspection and a clear disclosure. The point is to know where you stand before a buyer's lender does, not after you're under a deadline in a Purchase and Sale Agreement.

FAQ

How old does a roof have to be before insurance companies restrict coverage in Massachusetts?

There's no single age. Each insurer sets its own rules, and consumer insurance guides commonly describe roughly 15 to 20 years as the range where asphalt shingle roofs get more scrutiny. Some insurers may decline an older roof, while others cover it only at actual cash value instead of replacement cost.

What happens if my buyer can't get insurance because of my roof?

The buyer's lender won't fund the mortgage without proof of insurance. That can delay or end a sale late in the process. A documented roof inspection or repair can sometimes resolve the issue without a full replacement.

Do I have to replace my roof before selling my Boston home?

Not necessarily. The question is whether the roof's age and condition will let a buyer's insurer write a policy. A professional inspection showing the roof's condition can sometimes satisfy an insurer even when the roof is older.

What is the Massachusetts FAIR Plan?

The FAIR Plan, formally the Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association, offers homeowners and dwelling fire policies for eligible properties whose owners can't get insurance in the regular market. A buyer whose private insurer declines a home with an older roof can ask an insurance agent about it.

Are letters saying my roof was "flagged" for insurance real?

Not always. In November 2025 the Massachusetts Division of Insurance warned about roof "flagged" mailers from an entity that isn't an insurance company. A real nonrenewal notice comes from your insurer, at least 45 days before the policy expires, with the specific reasons. If a letter seems off, call your agent or insurer before acting on it.

The bottom line: if your Boston home has an older roof, find out its age and condition and what insurers will accept before you list, so a buyer's insurance question doesn't derail the sale late.

Sources

Have questions? Let's connect.

About Juan Murray

Juan Murray is a Boston broker associate with more than 30 years of experience helping buyers, sellers, and investors across Greater Boston, personally leading every transaction from the first conversation through closing.

RE/MAX Real Estate Center · (978) 581-0801

Equal Housing Opportunity. Juan Murray is licensed as a Broker in Massachusetts, regulated by the Massachusetts Board of Registration of Real Estate Brokers and Salespersons. This article is general information only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Confirm your specific costs and obligations with your closing agent, tax advisor, or lender.